Saturday, October 18, 2014

The Disney Princesses I Relate to the Most

You might be surprised by some of the rankings !

And ALL credit for photo goes strictly to http://disneyspersonalities.tumblr.com/






13. Ariel

I've never been able to relate that much to Ariel, which may be why she used to be one of my least favorites for a long time. I'm not outgoing, I've got social phobia, I'm more cautious, not that brave, and I'm not rebellious (when I have gone against what my dad wants, it's never big things, and I'd at least try to do it because I felt it was the right thing to do- otherwise, I'm a bit of a rule-follower). I could go on. I will say we're both impulsive, but I'm not dangerously impulsive! It's more because I'm so indecisive and can only make up my mind at the last minute which isn't always good for making wise choices. I think we're probably more alike than I see, but since this is about who I feel I relate to, she's gotta go last.

Too outgoing, adventurous, fearless, and reckless for me.
Too outgoing, adventurous, fearless, and reckless for me.

12. Merida

Merida and I aren't much alike and our interests are totally different. But I do get where she's coming from and like her, I've had a lot of problems with one of my parents as well. It's very frustrating when you don't communicate well with anyone, let alone your parent, who is the one who makes the rules for you. I'm not saying *I* would go to the trouble of making a deal with a witch and giving my mom or dad a magic cake, but I've also blown up at my dad a LOT over the years because he's very immature and I'm very impatient. So I at least understand her frustration. But since I've grown up I don't relate to the feisty/adventurous types much now.

Similar family problems, but too much of a willful tomboy.
Similar family problems, but too much of a willful tomboy.

11. Mulan

I don't think Mulan and I are totally different at all, but I've never particularly related to her either. When I watch the movie I don't really agree or disagree with anything she says or does. I don't know, I just feel rather neutral towards her here. But I do see similarities. We hold family high,we're rather awkward and dislike conflict. Though now that I think of it, I would probably also act similarly if I had to pretend to be a man. I'd be totally unsure of what to say that wouldn't give me away. Neither of us is outspoken until we're really determined about something. We're resourceful and analytical, but obviously she's much more so than I am because, well, Mulan kind of turns into a Mary Sue halfway into the movie where she can kick every guy's butt at everything and has no negative flaws for real people to relate to.

Socially awkward (where do people get 'outspoken' from?), loyal and analytical, but an alien situation to me, and much braver.
Socially awkward (where do people get 'outspoken' from?), loyal and analytical, but an alien situation to me, and a little too perfect to relate to.
 10. Snow White

When I was 16 and my dad got custody of me, I was totally in love with Snow White and understood her so well. I'm less silly and idealistic like her now, but I still relate to her in ways. I can be motherly and bossy too, and love a good romance. However, I've realized now she's much more outgoing and proactive than I am. I'd feel awkward waking up to see all those strange guys around me, and I'd probably have a harder time faring for myself in a strange situation. But a couple people told me I'm strong for getting through abuse, which is why I connected to her so much when I was younger. She NEVER lets anything bad get her down. Even when I feel depressed and negative, it's pretty easy to get me into a good mood again. We both easily see the beauty and goodness in life and people. She's only at 5 because the top 4 are a little more like me.But let me just say, her differences from me (outspokenness, confidence, leadership skills) are exactly why she's my role model, because I lack those traits!

Similar childhoods, naturally sees good, but more of a leader and none of my flaws.
Similar childhoods, naturally sees good, but more of a leader and none of my flaws
9. Elsa

On the surface I can see many similarities between us: we yearn for company like anyone else but also love solitude, we're artistic, quiet, and follow the rules. And speaking of her artsy side, I love the way she chooses to channel her angst- through art! She makes a whole palace! But even when I was way into the Frozen hype I had a hard time understanding where Elsa was coming from. I'm not sure if that's just me or inconsistent writing in the movie. I didn't get why she never even tried another way to control her powers, why she sent a snow monster after Anna, why she spends the whole movie trying to avoid hurting people if she's just gonna try to kill those guards, etc. Plus I tend to want to trust people more than she does. I'm not a big optimist, but I don't see the worst side of things either. But Elsa isn't that low because I still relate to the general aspects of her calm, quiet personality. If we could see more of her personality I might be able to see if I relate to her more.



Superficially similar, but difficult to relate to, especially her situation. I don't think she's "fierce" at all, either.
Superficially similar, but a bit difficult to relate to, especially her situation. I don't think she's "fierce" at all, either.








8. Rapunzel:

When I became apart of the Disney fandom for real a couple years ago, Rapunzel was the first modern princess I truly felt connected to. I hadn't seen Tangled yet and I was curious (it never looked that good to me but everyone said it was). I watched "When Will My Life Begin?" on youtube and just loved her! Like her, all I did was the same thing everyday (but for me, work- I would much rather have done domestic things all day because frankly homemaking sounds awesome to me) and wanted to get out and see more of life, but I couldn't. So I mostly relate to her for that song. But I also love art and have tons of hobbies. I hate being bored! I'd love to see the floating lights as a summer trip, but honestly I do not connect with her over those. I don't see the big deal- I thought the whole point of going was to see WHO is sending them and why, and I would have tried to find out, but she doesn't, she just sees them, and I never understood why. I would've felt like it was a huge waste of time if I never did what I meant to do there after all that traveling and danger I got into. I also wouldn't defy my parents that way and rationalize it. At best I probably just refused to clean my room when he was getting on my nerves growing up. Anyway, like with Belle they seemed to make her a little too perfect in their attempts at making both universally easy to relate to, but Rapunzel is made to be the quirky girl next door you could be best friends with in real life who is open with her emotions, and I relate to her more easily for this.

Designed to be relatable for everyone like Belle with a dorky personality and the "wanting more" goal, but a little too perfect and rebellious.
Designed to be relatable for everyone like Belle with a dorky personality and the "wanting more" goal, but a little too perfect and rebellious.
 
7. Jasmine
 It's said that what annoys us in others can tell us about ourselves, and I agree for the most part here. The things that annoy me most about Jasmine are some of the things I'm trying to overcome in myself: how quick she is to get annoyed and her sassy mouth. I'm a little impatient with people I think are being rude, although I wouldn't show it like she does. I know I can get really self-righteous in my anger when I think something is unfair or unjust. So some of my flaws are more like her's, but I would never take what I have for granted on such a big scale like that. I would also never resort to seducing Jafar like that! But still, I can identify with her better qualities, like her resourcefulness, honesty, and need to be true to ourselves. I would like to get out and see more of the world and I absolutely HATE people talking about me or my life like I'm not there too.

Relatable flaws and reactions; wants "more" but doesn't necessarily care about only that.
Relatable flaws and reactions; wants "more" but doesn't necessarily care about only that.

6. Tiana:

I think Tiana is very hard for most romance-loving, adventurous Disney fans to relate to for the same reasons I do relate to her: I may be imaginative and daydream a lot but I'm pretty grounded too. I'm very religious, but I try being reasonable and not just expect something to work just because I have the confidence. I also don't believe wishing on stars really does anything (though I do believe in fate). Mostly, though, it's her situation I relate to. I'm around her age and all I do is work! But unlike her, I would love to take a vacation; I just can't afford it. It feels like all I do is work. I don't have a specific goal like her, but I am a hard worker and I would treat Naveen the same way if he was that rude to me. I'm also opinionated, want my work to have some purpose to it, and want to make my parents proud of me. We're still pretty different in ways (I'm not nearly as ambitious, and I think she's too judgmental towards other people). However, I don't really look down on people for not being as obsessed with hard work and ambition as she is.

Sassy, practical working girls. Nuff said. VERY different desires, though.
Opinionated, practical working girls. Nuff said. VERY different desires, though.

5. Anna
Ah, Anna. I thought you'd be a generic spirited young lady, and yet here you are this high! I was very surprised how strongly I related to Anna. the more I analyze the sisters, the more I understand Anna and the less I get Elsa. (Sorry, Elsa.) I have had bouts of loneliness, even though I'm much less socially bold than she is, and I also liked the wrong guy once. We're both VERY AWKWARD. No kidding. At least, cute/smart guys definitely make me feel this way too. People at work think I'm shy and "need to smile more" but I've always considered myself happy and light-hearted like Anna, honestly, and just because I'm not adorably smiley like she is doesn't mean I can't feel optimistic and happy on the inside. She's MUCH braver and more reckless than I am, but I still connect with her a lot. I also love an anti-social guy who likes antlered animals (moose, though, not reindeer), love animals, am very honest about my feelings. We're impulsive to a degree, but less so than Ariel so I relate more to her for that.

Naturally light-hearted, awkward dorks who shouldn't listen to our hearts so much.
Naturally light-hearted, awkward dorks who shouldn't listen to our hearts so much.
4. Belle

I used to not relate to Belle at all, which is why she used to annoy me so much, I guess. I never understood her, like why she never had an adventure if she wanted one soooo badly. Well, now I see it's just because she's too loyal and responsible to go. I would be the same way. I also didn't get that she's just lonely, which is how I feel a lot of the time now. I also don't have a lot of people I can confide in and my boyfriend doesn't even live in my country. I also love books, but hobbies don't make me relate to a character. I like to think I'm more grateful for what I have and I'm not as brave. But looking back, I can kind of see some similarities- I'm a bit of a Disney snob like she's kind of an intellectual snob, we love solitude but still want to connect to people, and a part of me still wants adventure "in the great wide somewhere" while I'm stuck in this place. And we're both kind of hipsters. When I was a teen I had this annoying "I'm deep and intellectual and hardly anyone else is" phase too. All right, I still like some hipster stuff and enjoy being different (hopefully not in a special snowflakey way). But we deal with people very different- she usually stands up for herself without thinking if it'll get her into trouble, while I sometimes don't if it isn't worth the trouble. I'm very open about how I feel, and when Belle doesn't do this the Beast almost dies. But I'm surprised how much I can identify her, really, even if she's not my favorite, which shows you don't necessarily have to like someone to relate to their feelings or situation.

Fantasy escapist hipsters, but different ways of thinking and dealing with people.
Fantasy escapist hipsters, but different ways of thinking and dealing with people.
3. Cinderella

By this point, it's REALLY hard to rank them because I relate to them almost equally. The list might change later on.Some people have said it's only Cinderella's story that everyone can relate to, not Cinderella herself. Well, for some maybe, but I think anyone can relate to her personality. Who hasn't felt frustrated by unfair circumstances beyond their control? Or felt like taking it on out someone else (ahem, Lucifer)? Or fall right away for the first guy who treats you well? The general bits aside, I very much relate to Cinderella's personality. I suppose this is partly why I've always seen her as a very realistically written heroine. She's so frustrated with her unfortunate lot in life but she's a naturally upbeat person who is good at stuffing that frustration to save herself pain. I'm not stuck with an abusive parent anymore, but I VERY much connect to that, even now. I'm stuck working a job I don't think I'm that good at and I'm constantly frustrated with being around hordes of people all the time, thanks to social phobia. I'm pretty stoic and my mom used to get so angry when I didn't show emotion when she wanted me to (so she could yell at me more, as I'm sure Tremaine wanted Cindy to). She has plain resentment and even a temper she can't always hide, and I'm that way as well, and I don't even have her level of admirable patience. We're also quiet, not really solid optimists OR pessimists in general, like fashion, and are pretty protective of our pets/family.

Stoic but daydreaming realists with relatable backgrounds, flaws, and attitudes toward our lives.
Stoic but daydreaming realists with relatable backgrounds, flaws, and attitudes toward our lives.
2. Aurora

Of all the princesses that get called too perfect, I understand why Aurora is accused of this the least. Half the time she's criticized as weak, so how can she be both flawed and perfect at the same time? I'm a lot like her and I'm sure not perfect. I'm not just awkward around strangers, I'm phobic. I don't know what to say to guys either, and I can be pretty flustered if I have to make a quick decision like that. I love that we have such an introverted, shy princess who is allowed to stay that way and not have to change into a more outspoken person! Maybe it's because I've spent tons of time analyzing Aurora, but I don't think she's really as hard to relate to as people say. Are you telling me nobody has ever both loved their guardians but resented their overprotectiveness/rules? Or, like I said with Cindy, crushed on the first guy you connect with? And her imaginative side too. (On another note, Elsa has roughly 20 minutes of screen time to match Aurora's 20 minutes, so why is one seen as so ~relatable~ and the other as too unrelatable and hard to understand?) Now, there's several different types of intelligence. I took a quiz on it and apparently I've got the intrapersonal ("self-reflective") kind where you wonder about your own life and are very aware of your emotions and how you'd react to future circumstances. I believe Aurora is the same way (I might have to do an article on what type each DP has now). I always think about my life, my past, and well as things I'd love to have happen but know they probably won't ("But... it's only in my dreams..."). I'm so quiet and stoic-looking I always wonder if people see me as cold, but if you know me you'll know how emotional I am. Like Aurora, sometimes I listen a little too much to my heart and this can cause disappointment, and we both try to do the right thing, even if we would rather actually do what our hearts want. Really, I could write an essay on how alike I think we are, which should tell you something about Aurora supposedly being a two-dimensional character.

Abundance of flaws, values, and attitudes shared between two artistic, reserved, fragile escapists.
Abundance of flaws, values, and attitudes shared between two artistic, reserved, fragile escapists.

1. Pocahontas

I'm so glad people have been studying Pocahontas' character more, because it's opened my eyes to what a good character she is. I can identify strongly with some things she goes through- not war, of course, but for years, and right now, I'm still struggling to find out what my purpose in life is. What is my destiny? How will I know when to act to fulfill it? Like with Pocahontas, this can cause me to seem passive to others and be indecisive. And like her, I do pray for guidance which can REALLY make me look passive and indecisive. I do also lean on the advice of others quite a bit- I don't know everything about every situation and I like seeing things from different perspectives to figure out the best way of dealing with a problem before acting on it. We both REALLY want to make sure we're doing the morally right thing and not just be blindly proactive. I also love nature too- if I had her kind of freedom, I'd love to be able to explore and see every hill and tree and "go wherever the wind takes me". I've admitted this a lot too- I can be preachy. Pocahontas has a WHOLE SONG where she does nothing but preach about respecting people and the earth. It's hard for us both to just get to the point when there's SO much to say! I also hate conflict. I mean, I argue with my friend and boyfriend a lot, but it's mostly in jest. I HATE too much negativity in the air. In relation to this, we don't always speak up for ourselves. Like I mentioned with Belle, I won't mention how I feel if it'll just cause needless drama. I try to when I see the need to though. Pocahontas also doesn't always stand up for herself (and this causes a domino effect of trouble). The only things I don't really relate to are her rebellious side and some of the INSANELY daring stuff she does. I ain't even standing on the edge of a cliff, much less diving off like some Olympic athlete.

Spiritual nature-lovers who dislike conflict, share flaws, and desire to find our purposes in life.
Spiritual nature-lovers who dislike conflict, share flaws, and desire to find our purposes in life.
So, I tend to relate to the more emotional, perceptive, artsy-but-also-proper girls, especially if they're introverts. I've never related to many outgoing girls, despite Anna and Snow White being fairly high, but Snow White isn't as bold about it as Ariel and Anna is pretty dorky for a sociable person. I try to analyze the heroines more before just connecting to them for the usual superficial reasons people list (i.e. "Belle and I are just alike because we like reading!" or "I relate to Aurora because we love to sleep !"). I mean, they're all well-rounded characters, so why not look deeper since you can? ;)

Wednesday, October 8, 2014

Snow White Was Not an Idiot: In Defense of the Apple

It kills me that Snow White gets so much hatred for her ONE mistake (one made with very good intentions I might add) than any of the other princesses or heroines do. I would say Belle made the biggest two- letting her stalker Gaston into her home while she was alone, and then the infamous "Well, he told me not to go into the West Wing... so I better go do it, YOLO!" scene. Why is Belle seen as so intelligent despite also letting in a possibly dangerous person AND going into a dangerous place alone, but poor Snow is branded a moron for just trying to help what she believed was "a poor old lady"? Or how Jasmine had no hesitation about going into the house of a strange man by herself? Or Rapunzel trusting a thief who broke into her home and deciding to go on a road trip with him? I could go on. Notice how even the "smart princess", as she's universally and unfairly called and stereotyped as, does possibly does the least intelligent things of them all. Why single Snow White out when they all made mistakes and trusted strangers?

credit: waltdisneyconfessions.tumblr.com


Let's look at the movie:

1. Snow White doesn't immediately let her in. The hag takes her by such surprise that, like Aurora, she forgets she isn't supposed to speak to strangers.
2. Snow only lets her in because she thinks the old lady is having a heart attack. What a terrible person, trying to help someone! She isn't the type of person to just let an old person collapse on the ground.
3. Snow is obviously nervous when she starts to offer the apple. She clearly starts trying to stall having to accept it (talking a lot about her wish, and she sounds a little apprehensive). She doesn't immediately gobble it up.


That sounds like how a lot of people normally react when they are surprised, alone, and suddenly have a strange person in their midst, much less when they are a sheltered 14-year-old girl. Was it wrong to do? Of course. When has anyone ever advocated going along with a stranger (except for Sandor lovers/Sansa haters in the A Song of Ice and Fire/Game of Thrones fandoms, of course)? But stupid? No, unless you count the other girls doing the same thing stupid too, which most people don't. I think given that she didn't seem to ever be taught not to trust strangers, yet was still hesitating to trust this one, shows she isn't stupid for this.

If you're going to blame one person for a weakness, you need to be fair and blame the others for theirs too, especially if they know better. Don't single one out just because everyone else is!

A Rapunzel Rant (and Unpopular Opinion)

Rapunzel, the iconic fairy tale heroine and one of the most popular Disney Princesses today, beloved by little girls for her brushable silk tresses and older fans for her quirky personality and humorous movie. But some things bother me about this oft-praised heroine.

Hair of gold, heart of gold, right?

It annoys me that people love her for the exact same reasons they hate Snow White (who is my favorite princess ever, next to Aurora, and really doesn't get the credit she deserves). And a lot of them are just hypocritical about them in general. Rapunzel’s mistakes --if you can call them that, because the movie sure thinks they're good-- are excusable; Snow’s are not, despite the fact that one involved a princess rebelling just so she could have her way, and the other was a princess being too kind for her own good. Rapunzel’s bubbly, perky, naive personality is adorable; Snow White’s is annoying. Rapunzel is so proactive despite staying in her tower for 18 years; while Snow White, who actually makes a lot of choices herself and dominates a household full of men, is somehow “passive”, and this is somehow a bad thing. Rapunzel needs rescuing a lot for things she gets herself into but is feminist; Snow White gets put under a spell and she’s a feminist’s worst nightmare. Rapunzel wants to see lanterns and this is an inspiring dream; Snow White simply wants love for once in her life and this is stupid and sexist. This isn’t Rapunzel’s fault at all how her fans treat her and her fellow princess, of course, but it annoys me because most of her fandom is bad about this.
Hmm, a pretty fairy tale girl sitting around talking to cute little critters in a puffy-sleeves dress in the sunshine... who does this remind me of?

 Now, anyway, I disliked her before the film came out (really fair, I know, but in my defense, many radical feminists made her sound like she was their poster girl). Then I saw it and loved her. Then I analyzed it and didn’t like her as much.

Disney really played it safe with her, like, they just took qualities from every past heroine and put them in her. She just overall feels too… carefully constructed, meant to appeal universally to little girls who like pastel dresses, cute animal sidekicks and long blonde hair (granted, that is canon) and and their Disney-apprehensive parents. Everything about her says “Made by Disney Co.!” I like her still, in theory, but feel she’s more of a marketing tool than an original, well-rounded character. Even her hobbies are plentiful, meant to have one for pretty much any kid to see they also like, instead of making a more distinct personality.



As for hidden princesses with blonde hair and a dashing prince with an amusingly stubborn horse, I actually prefer Aurora and think she has a more layered, organic personality in her 23 minutes of screen time. I like that while she has been kept at home all her life, she doesn’t run away even after she meets someone she clicks with, she doesn’t defy her guardians and rationalize her rebellion like Rapunzel, which is the one thing I truly can’t like about Blondie.

Hmm, a barefoot, free-spirited blonde princess hidden away from the world, talks to animals, and falls in love with the first man she meets... Geez, Disney, ever heard of originality?!

OK, I really hope that didn’t make it sound like I despise Rapunzel or anything, because I don’t, but Tangled bothers me for various reasons. I still watch it quite a bit though- love the animation and it’s very entertaining. But the designated heroes aren't very admirable, and the standard "follow your heart not your morals" is one that needs to stop being presented as good by our fictional role models.